The 2007 movie Becoming Jane, directed by Julian Jarrold, is a historical film inspired by the early life of famous novelist Jane Austen (played by Anne Hathaway) and her relationship with Tom Lefroy (portrayed by James McAvoy). Jane Austen is the youngest daughter of Reverend Austen (James Cromwell) and his wife (Julie Walters). She has yet to find a suitable husband. Jane desires to become a write, to her mother’s dismay, and the delight of her father. Thomas Lefroy is a promising lawyer but has a bad reputation that he describes as “typical” for companions of that era. His wealthy uncle is unhappy with his behavior and sends him to the countryside to learn his lesson. After a bad first impression upon meeting Mr. Lefroy, Jane cannot stand the arrogant Irishman.
Throughout the movie, Jane turns down the affections of numerous men including Mr. Wisley (Laurence Fox), the nephew of Lady Gresham (Maggie Smith). She denies his proposal. Tom and Jane’s hate soon begins to turn into a growing affection. The mischievous Tom continues his advances and Jane begins to take the idea of marriage seriously. They get to know each other gradually, and eventually fall in love.
Tom, Jane, her brother and cousin receive an invitation from Tom’s uncle and benefactor (the Lord Chief Judge Langlois of London). The judge was about to give his blessing for Tom and Jane’s marriage when he received an anonymous letter informing him that Jane’s family was poor and refuses to give the blessing. Jane is upset when Tom tells her that he can’t marry her, not knowing that Tom had a good reason; he is his family’s only hope for survival. Jane goes back home and accepts Mr. Wisley’s proposal that she earlier turned down.
Tom soon realizes that he cannot live without Jane and comes back suggesting that they should runaway. Jane agrees and leaves with only her sister Cassandra knowing. On the way, Jane stumbles upon a letter from Tom’s mother, and realizes his situation. She tells Tome that they can’t do this with so many people depending on him. Tom insists otherwise but Jane says that he won’t be able to support his family if he runs away. Jane says that she loves him, but that if their love destroys his family, it would destroy itself with guilt, regret, and blame.
Tom was an inspiration for some of Austen’s writing (Mr. Darcy in Pride and Prejudice). Jane destroyed most of the evidence of their relationship. Twenty years later Jane encounters Thomas Lefroy at a social function. He is with his eldest daughter also named Jane, who turns out to be a big fan of Jane’s writing.
At 22 minutes and 45 seconds into the movie, Jane and Tom both meet unexpectedly in the woods. Tom was sent by his uncle (that lives in the country) into the woods to learn a few things about the beauty of the country. Tom was struggling to make his way through while Jane was taking a pleasant walk and was unhappy when she saw the arrogant man who had insulted her writing. In this shot we see Hathaway’s character on the complete opposite side of the screen compared to McAvoy. We get something between a full or medium shot of Jane and a long distance shot of Tom. He is emerging from the thicket to the trail and trying to get to Jane, whereas she is walking away, not wanting to be in his presence. The depth of field shows that the two are deep inside of the forest because each side of the shot is surrounded by green shrubbery and trees. Though you see the two on opposite ends on the screen, you are forced to look at the space between them. In this shot you see the open gap occupied by only the green and brown path. This empty space will fill up in the next few shots as Tom gets closer to Jane. It shows the aversion between the two, but also the developing chemistry (each step they take to get closer is filling up that empty gap). In my opinion this is an eye level shot. When you watch this scene, at the time Jane is closer to you but soon Tom is right next to her and it becomes a full and then medium shot. It’s as if you are standing on the path, watching this happen.
This shot is in the perfect spot in the forest. There is a peaceful path that Jane is walking on in her casual but nice blue dress with a white collar. The dress is very plain but you can tell it’s something that might have been worn in the 1800s for an average person. Even her hair is up the way a woman might have worn it then. Tom is dressed in a very elegant black suit with a nice waste coat, white shirt, top hat, and cane. It’s ironic. We can tell that he is from the city and doesn’t fit into the country style.
How do you think the character’s positioning (where they are and how they’re standing) affects the mood and point of this shot? If you didn’t know what this movie is about, what would you conclude by just seeing this shot?
Do we comment on our own?
ReplyDeleteOkay... well I'll just say my quick opinion. Mr.Cowlin, you expressed your liking for the off center frame. I personally think it adds to the shot, i that it makes you look at the empty space between them. There may be a forest and path, but its empty. If I had not seen this movie I would say that A) Jane is either unaware of the man not far behind her or B) she is ignoring him and walking away while he is following her (almost like a stalker) trying to get to her. This could represent tension between them and perhaps a bad relationship or acquaintance in the past. As the space fills in I would guess that they are either about to argue or come to an agreement. And in fact in the movie its both. They express their dislike for each other but then become on better terms
ReplyDeleteI've been watching the Showtime series Dexter this week. It contains lots of shots that are perfectly centered. This creates symmetry. So do shots like this one, with two subjects equally balanced on either side of the frame. I'm wondering what the rest of you think about symmetry (the left side being identical to the right), and what effect it can create within a shot.
ReplyDeleteBrandon Stark
ReplyDeleteI can tell by the view of this scene and where the character's locations are it shows there's a little block in thier relationship stopping it from progressing. You can also see that the man truly wants the girl. He's willing to work to get the girl and do anything for her. You can tell by the way Anne Hathaway's character that she doesn't want the guy and is looking away from him showing that she's in no intrest to be with him. You can tell that both of them will have to accept eachother for who they are for their relationship to work.
Owen Moynihan
ReplyDeleteThe fact that both characters seems to try and show that neither one by themselves is the focus. Without knowing what the movie was about I would think that the man in black in the background was a stalker and possible murder and the woman was his next victim, almost like Jack the Ripper.
In my opinion, it looks like Jane has a lot more power in this scene because of how the trees are all balanced towards her side, and Tom is just barely visible in the background. It emphasizes how Jane knows her way through the forest, while Tom like you said is "struggling to make his way through". Jane has the upper hand at the moment. It also seems like the characters had bad first impressions of one another. Especially on Jane's part I feel like she is extremely annoyed. You can tell with the expression on her face and her clenched fist. And I feel like Tom doesn't even know he did anything to offend her, he's just annoyed because he has to walk so much. By looking at this shot, I would conclude that the two (Jane and Tom) will end up together, and Tom will be the one to propose to her, because even though he is in the far distance, he is facing and angled directly towards her.
ReplyDeleteIt's obvious by the distance between them that she doesn't want to be near him. This affects the mood because it tells the audience that there is something going on in between them causing distance-- both literally and figuratively. I definitely haven't seen this movie, and just by a quick glance at the frame I can tell Jane is both running away from something, and is troubled. It's my lucky guess that the cause of both of that is the Tom. Great choice of frame :]
ReplyDelete